- Miroslav Djokic1,*⇓,
- Elisabet Björklund1,
- Elisabeth Blennow2,
- Joanna Mazur3,
- Stefan Söderhäll4 and
- Anna Porwit1
- 1 Department of Pathology, Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm;
- 2 Department of Molecular Medicine, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm;
- 3 Department of Child and Adolescent Health, Institute of Mother and Child, Warsaw, Poland and
- 4 Children’s Cancer Research Unit at Astrid Lindgren Children’s Hospital, Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden
- Correspondence: Miroslav Djokic, Department of Pathology, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, 200 Lothrop Street, G316, Pittsburgh, PA, 15090, USA. E-mail:
We evaluated CD123 expression in 95 pediatric and 24 adult ALL patients and compared the results with the CD123 expression in normal B-cell precursors. Early B-cell precursors were negative while intermediate precursors and mature B cells showed weak CD123 expression. Leukemic blasts in 31% of precursor-B ALL samples exhibited strong expression of CD123, 61% had moderate CD123 expression and 8% were negative; 81.5% of ALL with hyperdiploid karyotype (≥ 52 chromosomes) showed strong CD123 overexpression. In contrast, cases with ETV6/RUNX1 rearrangement had weak CD123 expression. Our study suggests that overexpression of CD123 is an aberrant phenotype present in a subset of precursor-B ALL with hyperdiploid genotype, and represents an additional marker of good prognosis in pediatric precursor-B ALL. Moreover, aberrant CD123 expression in ALL is a good marker for monitoring of minimal residual disease.
CD123 is an α subunit of a heterodimer IL-3 receptor, a member of the cytokine receptor superfamily.1,2 It is a 70 kDa protein, which binds IL-3 with high specificity but with low affinity.3 CD123 is encoded by the IL-3a gene, located in the pseudo-autosomal region (PAR) at the ends of the short arms of the X and Y chromosomes (Xp22.3 and Yp11.3).4 B-lymphoid blasts from acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) have been shown to express functional CD123 and CD40 ligand stimulates proliferation of precursor-B (pre-B)ALL by upregulating CD123 expression.5,6 However, the prevalence of CD123 expression in pre-B ALL is not clear: one study of 13 B-ALL cases reported CD123 expression in all cases as significantly higher than normal B-cell precursors.7 Another study (25 pre-B ALL cases) found 40% of pre-B ALL to have high CD123 expression in comparison to human myeloid and lymphoid progenitors.8
Our goal was to characterize the expression of CD123 in different maturational stages of normal B-cell precursors in the bone marrow by comparison to leukemic blasts of pre-B ALL, using multiparameter flow cytometry (FC). We also sought to establish if the level of CD123 expression in ALL correlated with any recurrent genetic abnormality. Finally, we investigated whether the overexpression of CD123 on residual leukemic blasts can be applied for follow-up of minimal residual disease (MRD).
Design and Methods
A total of 95 consecutive diagnostic samples of childhood ALL (89 newly diagnosed, 6 at relapse, mean age six years, range 0–18) were collected from December 2001 to October 2004. Samples from 24 adults with newly diagnosed ALL (mean age 48 years, range 21–78) were collected between December 2002 and March 2005. The diagnosis of ALL was established according to WHO 2001 criteria.9 Immunophenotype was classified according to EGIL:10 among pediatric ALL cases there were 5 BI, 60 BII, 20 BIII and 10 T-ALL, and among adults 2 BI, 14 BII, 5 BIII and 3 TALL.
All children were karyotyped, and in most cases, additional genetic analyses, including interphase FISH, SKY, or PCR for BCR/ABL1, ETV6/RUNX1, PBX1/TCF3 and MLL rearrangements, were made as part of the routine investigations.11 Genetic abnormalities in childhood pre-B-ALL cases included 26 cases with hyperdiploid karyotype, 18 with ETV6/RUNX1, 2 with BCR/ABL1, 2 with PBX1/TCF3, 4 with MLL gene rearrangement, and 11 with normal karyotype; 18 cases showed abnormal karyotype with non-recurrent cytogenetic abnormalities. Karyotypes were available for 13 of 21 adult patients with pre-B ALL: 3 with BCR/ABL1, 1 with MLL gene rearrangement, 1 hyperdiploid, 3 with normal karyotype and 5 cases with non-recurrent genetic abnormalities.
Hospital control (HC) BM samples for studies of non-leukemic B-cell precursors were obtained from 28 patients: 15 children (median age seven years, range 0–18) and 13 adults (median age 63 years, range 20–84) with normal patterns of B-cell differentiation in the bone marrow. HC patients were investigated due to anemia, leukopenia, reactive lymphocytosis, staging of malignant lymphoma, suspect but not confirmed myelodysplastic syndrome or myeloma, and included children who were at least six months post-maintenance therapy for leukemia with no evidence of disease recurrence. In addition, the expression of CD123 on regenerating B-precursors was analyzed in 42 BM samples taken during follow-up of patients who were a part of the childhood ALL cohort, but as shown by the extensive FC analysis (see below) did not have any MRD after induction therapy (8 follow-up samples were taken at day 50 post-induction therapy, 29 samples were taken at day 103, 2 samples were taken six months post-induction and 3 samples were taken 12 months post-induction therapy. Non-leukemic B-cell progenitors were categorized as early, intermediate, and mature B cells by expression of CD10, CD20 and/or CD34 on CD19-gated cells as previously described.12
Immunophenotypic studies were performed by standard four-color FC13 and included the combination: CD66c-FITC/CD123-PE/CD19-PerCP/CD34-APC.
All studied patients were uniformly treated by NOPHO 2000 protocol and followed by FC for detection of MRD.13 MRD follow-up panels were individually tailored depending on aberrant findings at diagnosis.
The most commonly applied antibody combinations with CD123 were: CD66c/CD123/CD19/CD45, CD34/CD123/CD19/CD10, CD19/CD123/CD20/CD33, TdT/CD123/CD19/CD10, CD56/CD123/CD19/CD45 and CD19/CD123/HLADR/CD10. MRD was defined as a cluster of at least 10-20 events with aberrant phenotype.
The clustered events had forward and side scatter characteristics identical to those of leukemic blasts at diagnosis.
Overall, samples for immunophenotypic studies included bone marrow (BM) aspirate (n=189), peripheral blood (n=16), and cell suspension from lymph node biopsy or fine needle aspirate (n=3). The CD123 expression was quantified by mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) in each gated cell population. A significant change in CD123 and other antigen expression in gated leukemic cells in follow-up samples were defined as a 1 SD increase or decrease of MFI by comparison to the MFI at diagnosis as calculated by the analysis software (Paint-a-Gate Pro, BD).
Descriptive statistical values including arithmetic mean, median, SD and range were used. Sensitivity and specificity were calculated according to the formula shown at http://www.cebm.utoronto.ca/glossary/spsn.htm). Comparisons of different cell populations were done by the Mann-Whitney U test and two-tailed Student’s t-test. All reported p values are two-sided. All calculations were performed using SPSS 12.0 (SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA) software.
The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Karolinska University Hospital in accordance with institutional research guidelines.
Results and Discussion
Hospital control samples (n=28) showed median values of 0.23% (range 0.01–1.03), 1.00% (range 0.04–20.50) and 1.72% (range 0.26–17.27) of early, intermediate and mature B cells in the bone marrow, respectively (representative pattern in a child is shown in Figure 1 A–D). The CD123 expression in normal B cells was low and showed median MFI values of 8 (range 4–26), 18 (range 5–36), and 9 (range 3–48), in three stages of maturation, respectively. CD34-positive B-cell precursors had a median CD123 MFI of 10 (range 4–39), while CD34-negative B-cell precursors had a median CD123 MFI of 13 (range 3–65). There was no significant difference in CD123 expression between studied subpopulations of B cells in HC BM samples and in regenerating (post-chemotherapy) B cells.
CD123 expression showed considerable variability in childhood preprecursor-B ALL. Six samples (7%) had no CD123 expression (MFI <10), 50 (59%) had intermediate expression (MFI 10–100), and 29 (34%) had strong expression of CD123 (MFI> 100), (Figure 1 E and F). Adult preprecursor-B ALL showed similar heterogeneity: 2 samples (10%) had no CD123 expression, 15 (71%) had intermediate expression, and 4 (19%) had a high CD123 expression (MFI>100). There was no correlation between expression of CD123 and other myeloid-associated markers, such as CD13 or CD33. Only a single case of T-precursor ALL showed CD123 expression with MFI=33 (7.7%). The immunophenotypic characteristics of this case were consistent with the most immature T-ALL recently shown to express CD123.14
When EGIL categories of B-precursor ALL were considered, the highest CD123 expression was found in EGIL B-II category (sc. common ALL) (p>0.001). This was probably due to a strong correlation found between high CD123 expression and hyperdiploid genotype. The hyperdiploid precursor-B ALL showed significantly higher CD123 expression than other major subcategories including ETV6/RUNX1, BCR/ABL1, MLL, PBX/TCF3 and B-precursor ALL with normal karyotype (Figure 2, p<0.0001). Twenty-two of 27 samples from patients with hyper-diploid ALL displayed CD123 MFI >100, but only 6 of 71 non-hyperdiploid precursor-B ALL showed similar high expression. The calculated sensitivity and specificity of high CD123 expression for hyperdiploid genotype are 81.5% and 91.5%, respectively, with a positive predictive value of 78.6%. Of interest, all cases with ETV6/RUNX1 showed uniformly low expression of CD123. However, some precursor-B ALL genetic categories (such as BCR/ABL1 and MLL rearrangements) were not frequent in our material and require further studies.
The overall CD123 expression in precursor-B ALL was significantly higher than in normal B cells (p<0.0001) of any maturation stage (Figure 2). Therefore, high expression of CD123 in preprecursor-B ALL can be defined as an aberrant or leukemia-related phenotype. CD123 overexpression could be used as leukemia-related aberrant phenotype for MRD follow-up in 60 of 106 (57%) of pre-B ALL patients in our cohort. High CD123 expression was one of the aberrant features confirming residual leukemia found in 22 samples (from 21 patients) taken at day 15 and/or day 29 post-therapy (see Figure 1 G and H). The CD123 showed stable overexpression in 77% samples with residual leukemia. By comparison, MFI of CD34 and TdT was stable in 32% and 31% of samples, respectively, as previously described by Gaipa et al.15
In conclusion, we found that CD123 expression is generally low in B-cell precursors and mature B cells both in HC BM samples and in post-chemotherapy regenerating B cells. The CD123 overexpression in B-precursor ALL correlated with hyperdiploid genotype, the second most common genetic abnormality in childhood ALL. In contrast, B-ALL samples with ETV6/RUNX1 rearrangement showed expression similar to normal B-cell precursors. The biological significance of CD123 expression in early precursor-B ALL with hyperdiploid genotype remains unclear. Analogous to the situation in acute myeloid leukemia, it may provide a proliferative advantage to leukemic blasts.16 The mechanism of overexpression is not known. However, 88% of children with high hyperdiploid karyotype have an extra X chromosome, on which the IL-3Rα gene is located.17 Whether a gene dosage effect may be responsible for the overexpression of this gene is not clear. The gene dosage hypothesis may be supported by a recent study of gene expression profiles in acute lymphoblastic leukemia, where Kuchinskaya et al. found that high expression of the IL-3Rα mRNA was one of the ten significant predictors of hyperdiploid phenotype (predictive strength 8.3). Besides the IL-3Rα gene, three other genes in this group were located on chromosome X.11
A remarkably stable expression of CD123 in residual leukemic cells during early therapy confirmed its reliability as a marker of MRD. It showed much less variation of expression than other commonly used markers for MRD including CD34, TdT, and CD10.
The high expression of CD123 in a subset of ALL may provide an important therapeutic target as has recently been suggested by Lhermitte et al.14 Diphtheria toxin fused to human interleukin-3 was shown to induce cytotoxicity in acute myeloid leukemia with CD123 expression.18 Our data suggest that CD123 expression should be evaluated in acute lymphoblastic leukemia for (i) its prognostic value as a predictor of hyperdiploid genotype, (ii) monitoring minimal residual disease at follow-up and (iii) to prospectively select patients who may benefit from the novel therapies.
↵* Current address: Department of Pathology, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Authorship and Disclosures
All authors contributed to conception, design, analysis and interpretation of data, drafting and critically revising the article for important intellectual content, and final approval of the version to be published.
The authors reported no potential conflicts of interest.
- Received September 9, 2008.
- Revision received February 13, 2009.
- Accepted February 17, 2009.
- Copyright© Ferrata Storti Foundation